(Note: There’s a question/plea for suggestions at the end of this long rambly post)

It’s happening. My boys are turning into…boys! Ok, yes they’ve been boys since the moment of their conception but they are turning into real boys these days even as hard as I’ve fought against it. For some reason I thought I could somehow raise my boys to be gentle, sweet, good-mannered and clean boys and keep them from turning into the icky nose-picking-farting-burping-and-all-sorts-of-other-loud-obnoxious-noise-making-touch-everything-in-site-never-sit-down-and-be-still stereotypical boys.

Alas I’ve slowly come to realize that no matter how hard I try, my boys are going to be boys. And really, I am ok with that (mostly). They have grown on me and have mellowed me down. Even though I grew up with 3 brothers (who I thought were mostly disgusting and annoying at the time) and have been married to my husband – a man who used to be a boy - for almost 10 years, I still have so much to learn about this male gender.  So far these boys have really humbled me and taught me a lot. They help me understand my husband better as I see what he might have been like as a kid. (It is a good thing we didn’t meet each other until later in life.)

I often wonder how different I would be as a mom if our first would have been a boy. Having a girl as our first set the tone for what I would expect of our first boy who came next. After the first year, our daughter has been really wonderful. She is (mostly) tame and sweet and obedient. Though she is definitely independent, she’s not overly rude about it. (I know, just wait until the teenage years right? Yikes).  She is curious and has an amazing imagination and sense of creativity, but she is still very dainty and sweet in her play. We could sit together and read a book for hours without moving around too much. I think I get restless before she does.

So when our second child, our first son, came along that was the only experience I had to go off of. And really, he has been very mild and sweet comparatively. He definitely has more of a stubborn temper than his older sister. He drives me pretty crazy with his inability to listen, focus, and remember what I asked him to do the way I asked him to do it. I often think about tying his hands together when we are at a store since he just can’t help but touch everything in sight and mess with it. (disclaimer: I would never actually do this) I should leave a tip at the end of our shopping trips for any damages they’ll find once we are gone. But my son’s sweet heart consistently wins me over. Ever since he was little, he’s always been very affectionate with me with lots of hugs and caresses. He definitely loves his momma. His dramatic facial expressions amuse me and his nerdy silliness cracks me up, when it doesn’t annoy me. :)




It’s only been after his little brother was born that the real boy in him started to come out. This third child has more of a “no-fear” complex than his more cautious older brother and he definitely acts more like a “typical” boy. He’s also rather goofy like his older brother.


I actually caught him trying to climb the door hinges in the bathroom the other day. I wake up drenched in sweat sometimes from nightmares of him trying to jump off our second-story staircase or fly from the playground convinced he can. But he’s still my sweet little baby. I think I will cry when this new baby is born when I see how big he’s really gotten.

As the 2-year-old grows up more it’s been “fun” watching how him and his older brother interact together more, for better or for worse.

A few months ago things were really rough with them both. The 5-year-old has been thrown off a little by his little brother’s new-found independence and incredibly strong will. He’s not the only one who doesn’t quite know how to handle this crazy little dude. It makes me a little nervous thinking about what this third boy will be like.

       (I’m not sure what they were pretending here but they were happy together at least)

Sometimes I think the 5-year-old gets confused about how to act with the little whirlwind but lately I think he’s taken the “if I can’t beat him join him” approach and joins in with his brother’s ornery wild side.

Dealing with these boys brings me to tears more often than I’d like to admit. When I try to control them and make them ‘change’ it usually just backfires in my raging face. The more I let go of control and just accept the chaos they naturally bring, the ‘better’ things seem to go…somedays. It’s a good thing I love them so darn much. When I spend more focused time with them it goes even better. I’ve also been trying to teach them how to share not only their toys better but also their trouble time. Hey if they can’t play nicely together they may as well share the same jail cell right?

        (Sharing “trouble” time under the “jail” desk)

       (He had to sit this one out alone…but Panda kept him company)

And when they aren’t in trouble or playing, I try and get them involved in work around the house and this really makes a difference…even though it too causes many squibbles and squabbles. I guess I’d rather hear them fighting over who gets to set the table or water the flowers for me than not help at all.

One thing I’m having a hard time with though is the whole guns/swords/hi-ya! stuff. I know, boys will be boys, yadayada, and they will make a gun or sword out of anything. Since we haven’t let any “real” toy guns/swords in the house (yet) they’ve been rather creative in what they turn into their swords.

      (A hammer)

     (Even an umbrella)

  (Be afraid)

(His kind sister made him a “real” one…and then his older brother crumpled it up later…)

I’m not as bothered by the swords idea. Guns are so violent and…final. Swords seem to carry more honor than a gun somehow. Maybe it’s because of the skill involved in sword fighting or all the pictures of gallant brave knights slashing evil dragons to save the damsel in distress. I’m not sure exactly.

However, when it comes to boys playing swords vs. guns, I have to agree with Amber Dusik of Crappy Pictures, that playing guns can be ”safer” than playing with swords since they involve more physical contact than guns.

     (A swishing ruler can inflict some real pain)

Good point aside, watching my boys shoot at each other still makes me grimace and shift around uncomfortably. When I was younger, I detested guns and swore I would never allow my boys to play with them. I did everything I could to stop my little brothers from playing guns. I still hate guns but I haven’t enforced any “no playing with guns” rule for our boys yet. Although my husband (surprisingly to me) was the first to say no to bringing toy guns in the house, even water guns. (Now that I think of it this might have been only because he didn’t want them squirting water in each other’s faces. hmm.) I also haven’t told my boys they can’t play guns with other boys who are playing this way. This would be an impossible rule to enforce unless I never let them play with other boys. I also don’t judge other parents in their gun-playing decisions…unless they allow their children to become overly violent or crude about it then I speak up in defense of my own children.

Is there a way to guide them so they can grow up to be men of honor and integrity…and yet still let them be the boys they are right now?

So what do YOU think? What thoughts/words of wisdom can you offer me on this subject of sword/gun fighting that can help me as I try and develop my own thoughts/policies for our family?

(p.s. this is not an invitation for judgement of what others do/don’t do, only asking for some helpful thoughts)

Related Posts with Thumbnails

8 Comments

  1. The gun thing is hard, and something I still need to wrap my mind around, but I agree, with boys I think it is unavoidable. Guns are more accepted at our house, simply because daddy hunts. So I guess when it becomes an issue (it hasn’t yet), that will be a good starting point for us. I hope others weigh in, I’ll be curious to hear a variety of thoughts on this.

       0 likes

  2. I totally love the pictures of your boys in this post, so much personality:)

    It has taken me some time to be comfortable with gun play. I remember when I first started my daycare I had all these preschool age boys and they wanted to make everything into guns and I really discouraged it. I think it was the article in Mothering magazine that gave me a much different perspective on it. I have never bought my kids toys guns but they have toys nerf guns and they can make anything into guns. We have set boundaries with weapon play. It’s funny to me that I was so against gun play because I vividly remember loving the cap guns I had as a kid. I think it is understanding as a parent of the power of guns. Anyway just a few thoughts. I need to see if I can find that Mothering article, but I think it was very similar to what was in the blog post that I linked to you.

       0 likes

  3. I’d like to see that article as well.

       0 likes

  4. I found that article last night. The perk of having my old Mothering magazines organized so well :) It still is a very good read. It is from Nov/Dec 2006. You might be able to find it on their website. I will plan on bringing it to CM next week.

       0 likes

  5. i can see your point about swords being associated with more valiant battles, but unless your kids are familiar with the chronicals of narnia, i don’t know of too many other children’s stories that really go into swords a whole lot. i’m sure there are plenty, i just cant think of many – which says to me that the “valiant sword fight” idea is more for us as adults than for the kids. anything can be a weapon. granted, i am a new mom, but it seems to me that the idea behind fighting with a weapon is more important than the weapon itself. if my son wants to wage war with someone to defend the honor of a sibling or to protect something, then i don’t care what weapon he uses. if he starts tearing through the house claiming to be a drug lord or a mobster and attacking things or people maliciously, then that’s the point at which i will become concerned. point being – a toy gun is no more dangerous in my mind than a paper sword, it is the intent behind the play that will concern me. maybe it’s because my husband is in the army, but that’s how i see it. :)

       0 likes

  6. Michelle, I think I remember reading an article about it too. I have some old magazines, I’ll see if I can find that one. If not I’d love to take a look at yours. Thanks for looking it up for me!
    I didn’t grow up with any hunters or a soldiers really in our immediate family or close group of friends but I see merit in both roles. Part of me hates the idea of my sons growing up and ever having to hurt/kill anyone. However, I also want them to understand that it is necessary to protect/defend yourself and your family. And, if all the grocery stores for some reason closed up shop, I’d like my boys to know how to provide for their families through hunting. It sounds like everyone agrees with this and that as long as we set appropriate guidelines and “monitor” the play it is ok.
    My 2-year-old is in a “bad guy” stage right now so I’ve been looking for good picture books of “good soldiers” for him to be inspired by. There are plenty of good knight books but it’s hard to find much with guns.

       0 likes

  7. i think if the worry is that if kids play with toy guns, they’ll grow up to be violent, that is totally unfounded and not to be worried about. we played guns sometimes, but mostly swords and bow and arrows a lot growing up and i’m yet to slash or impale anyone ; ) tim was a boy boy who loved playing guns as a kid (organizing the neighborhood into a civil war reenactment), still loves to shoot guns, and plays call of duty and other violent video games. but he’s also incredibly kind and compassionate.

    i think some boys are just going to be wild ones. i struggled with this too, and have tried to set the rule that they can play with guns as long as they don’t shoot each other, i’ve come to question even that rule. while it’s certainly unpleasant to hear your kid say, “i cut off your head” or “i shot you”, i don’t think it’s a sign of a disturbed child. you’re their momma and you know when what they are doing is just being wild boys and when it is too much and needs to be re-directed or discouraged. you’re doing a good job.

    oh and the touchy hands at the store-it makes me crazy!!! i totally sympathize.

       0 likes

  8. Thanks, Mary. I really appreciate your perspective. I know your kids play with guns and swords and it has never bothered me when my boys play together. I don’t necessarily feel “worried” about them playing with guns. It just makes me feel…”uncomfortable” but I can’t seem to put my thoughts/feelings more concretely than that. Like I said, I know it would ridiculous to force them or even expect them NOT to play like this. Maybe I’m just too much of a naive pacifist at heart.
    This might have been spurred by an incident we had at the park the other day with some other boys we didn’t know playing guns a little too aggresively. Maybe instead of ‘avoiding’ the subject and stupidly hoping they just won’t care about shooting and all that, I should take more time to talk with them honestly about it. Hmmm. Thanks for all the good food for thought!

       0 likes